Whether it was in the dim and distant past, or during your last job move, you've probably seen one. They look innocent enough. Gentle. Friendly. Encouraging. But deep down, are they being evasive? Yes, that's right: it's the Salary-Free-Job-Advert. It's been estimated that only 18% of organisations always publish specific salaries in their job adverts, and that only 41% always publish a salary range. But these elusive creatures of the job-hunting world may soon be a thing of the past; the government have announced plans to make potential employers include salaries in their job postings, and the internet is abuzz with strong opinions.
You'd think this would be met with universal rejoicing, wouldn't you? Many's the time we've all looked at a job advert, completely flummoxed as to whether or not the position's suitable for us. Is it too junior? Might you spend weeks of your life you'll never get back interviewing for the role, preparing presentations and revising obscure technical points late into the night, only to be told at the finish line that it pays a third of your current salary. Alternatively, is it actually a senior management role, requiring bucket-loads of industry experience, and is it a realistic possibility for you at this stage of your career? The irony is that some clarity would probably be in the best interests of the hiring team also. Who wants to spend hours wading through hundreds of applications from candidates who can't give them what they need? A clear expectation of the salary - and often by implication, of career stage - a particular role entails can save time, resources and stress for everyone.
There's also the fact that transparency generally increases equality - between genders, between those who have and don't have disabilities and between groups of different backgrounds. If existing team members can clearly see what new staff are being paid, the chances are that their own salaries will be brought into line and equalised. And equality, in turn, builds greater trust and employee satisfaction and loyalty. All of which are great news for those whose budgets may not stretch to the costs of regularly replacing and training up new team members.
And then there are the wider societal benefits. There's evidence to show that transparency in salary discussions at the point of hiring has a positive effect on the gender pay gap. Certainly, when the conversation is anchored in a particular place, the final salary figure is less likely to be dependent on individual negotiation skills - and dependence on these skills historically hasn't been good news for women or minority groups. For example, research shows that 57% of women have never negotiated for higher pay and a study by LSE shows that when no salary is fixed, women systematically ask for lower pay than comparable men when negotiating for jobs. More worryingly still, when they do negotiate, they have historically been met with different responses; one US study in 2002 showed that women were penalised significantly more than men for initiating salary negotiations. And each time this conversation takes place, in interviews all around the country, the impact reaches out across the years ahead for that applicant. When so many salary negotiations begin by asking a candidate about their existing salary, a lower starting point can easily trap women along a lower earnings trajectory over decades or even for their whole career.
Finally, it's true that there are particular groups who might find it more difficult than others to pitch their salary expectations at the right level - such as new entrants to the job market, and career returners. There isn't necessarily a magic formula you can use to calculate your own worth to an employer; the only benchmark you have is market norms, and it's very difficult to work out what these might be without clear data from advertised roles. If job adverts routinely omit this information, it may feel impossible to know where to start the conversation, or to summon the confidence to ask for what you think is an appropriate figure.
So it must be universally popular, yes? Well, not quite. Some in the HR industry are a little nervous about the possibility of unintended consequences. It's often said that women are less likely to put themselves forward for roles unless they can fulfil all of the criteria, whereas men are, overall, more willing to submit an application if they can meet some of the requirements. Might the inclusion of a high salary on job adverts actually deter some women from applying, in the same way that an extensive list of criteria may do? Is it the case that a bit of flexibility on salaries gives an employer more leeway to adjust its budget to accommodate the salary expectations of highly qualified and experienced applicants? Might some senior candidates decide not to respond to a job advert with a low advertised salary, when in reality, the company in question would have made them a salary offer which met the needs of both parties? Might the need to publish a salary disrupt what would otherwise have been a smooth and efficient hiring process? Finally, some have wondered whether making your team's salary rates publicly available gives information to your competitors which makes it easier for them to approach and hire your key employees?
Only time will tell which of these factors has the strongest impact on the world of work. The government's plans are still at a very early stage, and no doubt we'll hear further details over the coming months, but the announcement has sparked conversations across the UK about fairness, transparency and confidence. We think this is a great thing, and that we should all be able to discuss our salary expectations, loudly and proudly. Only when the taboos around salary discussions are broken down can we really move towards a future where everyone is rewarded fairly for what they bring to the table, whoever they are and wherever they come from. Perhaps in the years to come, everyone will be shown (an equitable amount of) the money.