NEET or Not?

Until today, you might not instinctively have felt that Alan Milburn and FDR were natural bedfellows.  I've never seen Milburn holding a cigarette holder between his teeth, nor wearing a naval cape. But the new deal-style proposals set out in a report published by Milburn today suggests they may have more in common than we think.

There's no denying that we have on our hands a crisis in youth unemployment - and that that's not good news for anyone. Around 1 million young people between 16 and 24 are currently considered to be NEETS – that is, not in employment, education or training. That's a whopping 13% of the population in that age bracket.  Something clearly needs to be done, to protect the futures of our young people - but is this report going to be key which unlocks those futures?

The Milburn Review has chosen to set its sights particularly on health, and on the balance between financial and practical employment support. This isn't an easy target.  Almost 30% of NEETS cite disability or ill health as the main reason that they're not in employment, education or training. Milburn says that we need to be offering these young adults more - or possibly less, depending on which way you look at it.  You see, the Review clearly has good intentions, but as always, the devil may be in the detail.  The most headline-grabbing of his recommendations is that the current health element of Universal Credit should be removed for young people and replaced with a separate Youth Allowance.  It also recommends that the number of apprenticeships should be doubled by 2036, and that the provision of post-18 college places should also be expanded, to offer greater training opportunities to young people.

Crucially, though, it also proposes radical changes at grass-roots level, which may make it easier for small businesses nationwide to employ and train young people.  It recommends that the government should raise the threshold at which employers need to start making National Insurance contributions from £5000 to £10,000 for young people working in retail and hospitality -in effect, making it cheaper to employ them. It suggests that fairly hefty cash incentives should be offered to employers for taking on NEETS; if a young person has been inactive for six months, a company might receive £3000 for employing them.  For the smallest companies, this may be a win-win situation. And finally, and perhaps most importantly, the Review recommends that every young person who's been out of employment, education or training for 12 months should be entitled to a guaranteed paid six month job. Overall, it's clear that the intention is to move away from a focus on youth benefits to a system which invests more heavily in getting people into work in the first place.

There are definitely some upsides to this concept.  The greatest stumbling block that young people have always faced when entering the workplace is their lack of experience.  And how can you gain experience when, you know, nobody will give you any experience?  If everyone has a guaranteed opportunity to gain that experience on the job, then that's likely to have positive effects which ripple out across their careers.  They can learn new skills, observe how people conduct themselves in the workplace and find out how to work with colleagues, of course. But they can also gain a good reference to put on their CV, and take those crucial first steps into the world of work that - let's all be honest about this - often feel a bit wobbly.  Even more than that, joining the working population after a period of inactivity is fundamentally good for you.  In general, joining the workforce is proven to build self-esteem and confidence.  The satisfaction and pride of a job well done brings a warm glow to everyone's heart, even those who might feel a bit jaded by years of economic inactivity.   It can also improve mental health - specifically, according to studies, because it structures your time, increases your social contact, gives you collective purpose, boosts your social status and gives you regular activity.  This is particularly important for NEETS, 20% of whom report mental health difficulties.  If they can overcome the risk of long-term economic inactivity, they are likely to end up happier and more fulfilled, as well as contributing more to the economy.

Hand in hand with this mental health boost is Milburn's plan to provide immediate, needs-based mental health support to NEETS, to help their entry into the workforce. This may be great news for the NEET generation. In many areas of the country, mental health support is patchy, amd may not be focussed on helping people access and retain work.  Assessment waiting lists for conditions such as ADHD or autism can be intimidatingly long, and people can sometimes fall between the gaps in provision.  The ability to access targeted, employment-focussed help without a formal diagnosis may possibly make the world of work more accessible to many young people.  

The boost to vocational routes is also important.  For many years, university has been seen as the pinacle of educational achievement in the UK.  Perhaps, though, it isn't the right path for everyone.  Around 1 in 10 NEETS are university graduates, so a degree won't necessarily guarantee you stable employment after graduation.  A wider choice of practical employment or training options might offer better career paths for many young people, many of whom are currently excluded from the more traditional entry models.  And finally, the bringing together of all of these services and information sources under one umbrella, the proposed new Youth Opportunity Service, may make it easier for young people to take that first leap into the workforce. 

However, whilst the general aims of the Review may be great, it's not clear whether they'll work for everyone.  The truth is that there are some people - young or less young - who may still face obstacles to accessing long-term employment, even with good-quality support.  It's estimated, for example, that 12% of NEETS are autistic or have learning difficulties.  Whilst of course it's crucial that we collectively support these young people to access the best employment opportunities possible, the process of filling in application forms, interviewing for a job, undergoing training and navigating a noisy, crowded, overstimulating commute can feel genuinely very difficult for some people - sometimes to the point where they experience serious and adverse effects.  A 6 month guaranteed job is a fantastic thing for most NEETS.  But for those who may always find it difficult to interview for, travel to or carry out a paid role - especially an in-person role - that won't necessarily change as a result of the proposed scheme; the more likely result is that they'll come to the end of their 6 month placement and will thereafter face the same challenges that they always did.  It isn't yet clear whether the proposed changes would recognise this and would be able to accommodate the needs of this community - perhaps by working with employers to offer opportunities for them to work remotely, and staggering start and finish times so that their commute could be easier.  If the system doesn't work for these NEETS, then it seems that they may be financially worse off in the long-run under the new proposals, even though their needs haven't changed.  

Even for NEETS without additional needs, it isn't clear that there will definitely be permanent roles for them to undertake at the end of the 6 month jobs they are being offered.  The number of vacancies in sectors which traditionally employ young people - such as hospitality, retail and health and social care - have plummeted in recent years.  Moreover, if all young people are being offered a 6 month job, on a rolling basis, then it seems unlikely that the number of vacancies in industries traditionally employing young people will be increasing any time soon.  Will they simply return to being NEETS?  Perhaps we need a more sustainable pathway to employment, which lasts longer than 6 months, and has a real prospect of a genuine paid role at the end of it?

There's also the geographical inequality of the NEETS' predicament to consider.  Studies have shown that the number of vacancies is far lower in some areas of the country than others.  You can undertake the best 6 month role in the world but if, at the end, there are very few vacancies in your area, then it may not be the passport to success that you might hope. In times past, young people might have been able to up sticks and move to an area with greater opportunities, but the cost of living has rather put paid to that in recent years, when increasing numbers of young people are living in the family home well into their twenties, out of economic necessity.

Then there are questions about the quality of the jobs that will be offered to young people under the guarantee scheme.  Of course, it would be great if they could gain valuable skills for the professional world, but without a robust framework, might they be used to fill less skilled vacancies for which employers don't need to offer any serious amount of training?  It isn't obvious, for example, how six months of working behind the scenes in a retail warehouse will help a young person to access an entry-level job in customer services, or office administration or marketing.  They can prove that they were reliable, punctual and could work as a team, of course.  Those skills are valuable, and offer real benefit to employers.  But are they enough on their own?  They won't necessarily teach young people how to send a professional email, or resolve a client complaint, or how to demonstrate creative problem-solving skills. In order to really move the dial, the scheme may need a range of employment opportunities—and presumably, an application system.  Will the scheme be funded sufficiently to do this?  Or is it going to be administered on a shoestring, so that it becomes a token gesture towards youth support?  Without proper financial backing, there's a risk that it may become only a parallel system of benefits - but, ironically, without much benefit.

Overall, then, there's definitely a lot to be positive about in the Review.  But in order to achieve the dizzy heights promised by the headlines, it'll need to be carefully implemented, and properly financed. It'll require the buy-in of a range of organisations, who are committed to providing real training and skills to young people.  And crucially, if we're trying to re-write the story of our young people's professional journeys, then this is a great first step - but it may need a sequel.  Without a follow-up, the adventure may stall in the first chapter.

Next
Next

Show Us The Money